https://twitter.com/1alexmason/status/1569873414617288706
Before the #EPlenary vote, some reflections from 6 years working on #EUBioenergy policies. TLDR: 1. They're accelerating climate change 2. We're wasting €billions 3. Don't believe a word the biofuel industry lobby says 4. MEPs must end support for burning trees and crops
The EU’s bioenergy policies are a serious threat to the climate. They’re encouraging things that increase emissions compared to fossil fuels, and so they're part of the problem not the solution.
The bioenergy criteria in the current EU Renewable Energy Directive are extraordinarily complex - and administratively burdensome for businesses - but are largely meaningless.
The GHG criteria exclude most of the important factors, and while sustainable forest management and LULUCF accounting are crucial for other reasons, they’re not a solution to the biomass problem - see our 2017 briefing paper for details. wwfeu.awsassets.panda.org/downloads/eu_b
And the Commission’s proposed changes in the #FitFor55 package will make little difference. Because what really matters in climate terms is WHAT you’re burning - i.e. the ‘feedstock’ - not HOW it was produced.
For example when it comes to woody biomass, there’s a huge difference in climate terms between burning tree trunks or stumps, and burning sawmill residues or post consumer waste.
800 scientists - including multiple IPCC lead authors and winners of the Nobel Prize and US Medal of Science made this point in a letter to MEPs in 2018, but the then Climate Commissioner@MAC_europa told MEPs not to vote for the relevant amendment. wwfeu.awsassets.panda.org/downloads/upda
Since then the @EU_Commission's own scientists in the@EU_ScienceHub have made clear that burning ‘coarse woody debris’ will typically increase emissions for decades compared to fossil fuels - time we don’t have to stop runaway climate change.
And that even burning ‘fine woody debris’ such as small branches will be comparable to fossil fuels in carbon terms for at least a decade or two - and by implication still a very high carbon energy source over a much longer period. publications.jrc.ec.europa.eu/repository/han
Unfortunately, 'fine woody debris' is the least of our problems. EU policy is leading to vast quantities of whole trees being burnt in the name of 'renewable energy' - see the photos from a majority of Member States in this @ForestDefence report. forestdefenders.eu/wp-content/upl
https://twitter.com/1alexmason/status/1569873414617288706
No comments:
Post a Comment